Fwd: [expertfinder-dev] Re: ExpertFinder Lunch Meeting/Expertise Vocab

[paola.dimaio at gmail.com]

Tom
thanks for replies
 very quick comments below


>
> Yes, possibly, although I think it would be interesting to gather a
> range of opinions on this list first. I have a very specific use case
> for this, and the Hoonoh vocab is based on the results of a previous
> study which I need to adhere to in pursuing this research further. So,
> in that context there isn't much scope for me to change the vocab that
> *I* use (apart from modelling decisions perhaps). If this same vocab
> (or just a few classes or properties) can be useful to the wider
> expertfinder community then that's great, I'd be really pleased. If on
> the other hand the community decides it needs to adopt a different
> approach or vocab that's fine too, of course :)


well, maybe we could use it a  a start of something else,

my personal opinion is that we should follow the SIOC
> approach, and integrate as closely as possible with FOAF, whilst not
> trying to actually add additional properties to the spec. I think
> trying to add new properties to FOAF itself may delay us
> unnecessarily.


I have been away - and keen to try to implement expertfinder but at the
moment not
sure how to hook the property expert to the object person, could you explain
in one line how sioc does that, or point me to relevant resource, thanks



>  the value would then be the different kinds of expertise etc
>
> Do you mean "different forms of expertise", or "expertise with regard
> to different topics"?


both I guess

Y
>
> So, I think we probably agree that expertise is a very multi-faceted
> concept ;) The challenge is to create a vocabulary that's simple, but
> sufficiently flexible to allow these subtleties to be represented.



well, yes , its worth clearing up a definition a little bit, so that we can
attempt to make all the relevant inferences and relationships properly

thanks

PDM


>
> >  so i would start from defining the property name, and after discuss the
>
> > rest of the issues?  makes sense?
> >
> >
> >  cheers
> >  Paola Di Maio
> >
> >
> >
> > <hoonoh:ExpertiseRelationship
> > rdf:about=3D" http://some-uri-for-this-expertise-relationship/">
> >      <hoonoh:from rdf:resource=3D"http://example.com/people/jack/" />
> >      <hoonoh:toTopic rdf:resource=3D" http://example.com/topics/beer/" =
/>
> >      <hoonoh:value>0.532</hoonoh:value>
> >  </hoonoh:ExpertiseRelationship>
> >
> >  <hoonoh:ExperienceRelationship
> > rdf:about=3D"http://some-uri-for-this-experience-relationship/">
> >      <hoonoh:from rdf:resource=3D" http://example.com/people/jack/" />
> >      <hoonoh:toTopic rdf:resource=3D"http://example.com/topics/beer/" />
> >      <hoonoh:value> 0.895</hoonoh:value>
> >  </hoonoh:ExperienceRelationship>
> >
> >  <hoonoh:AffinityRelationship
> > rdf:about=3D"http://some-uri-for-this-affinity-relationship/ ">
> >      <hoonoh:from rdf:resource=3D"http://example.com/people/jack/" />
> >      <hoonoh:toPerson rdf:resource=3D" http://example.com/people/jill/"=
 />
> >      <hoonoh:value>0.20</hoonoh:value>
> >  </hoonoh:AffinityRelationship>
> >
> >  </rdf:RDF>
>



-- =




Paola Di Maio *****
School of Information Technology
Mae Fah Luang University
Chiang Rai - Thailand
*********************************************


-- =




Paola Di Maio *****
School of Information Technology
Mae Fah Luang University
Chiang Rai - Thailand
*********************************************
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.usefulinc.com/pipermail/expertfinder-dev/attachments/2007=
0620/e3842a8f/attachment.htm